« Policy Change |
Main
| Overturning Betamax »
May 11, 2004
The Last Straw
Posted by Dana Blankenhorn
I don't like John F. Kerry. But I will vote for him.
I feel, now, that I must. To do otherwise is to endorse the horrors of Abu Ghraib. (The picture is from a site whose opinion here differs from mine, called Enter Stage Right. Consider it a form of equal time.)
I'm hearing a lot of rationalizations for those horrors, and the rationalizations, if anything, disgust me more than the horrors. The conduct was by "only a few." (No, it was systemic.) Our troops have performed heroically and selflessly. (Accepted, but this makes those sacrifices worthless.) The Geneva Convention doesn't apply to "terrorists." (The victims here were not proven terrorists.) What about Fallujah? (It happened many months later.) What about 9/11? (Iraq had nothing to do with it.)
You can't just fight fire with fire. You need water.
These attempts to rationalize horror and wipe the blood off our hands reminds me of nothing less than how Japanese patriots excused the militarism of their own country in the 1930s, a militarism that resulted in Pearl Harbor and, then, Hiroshima. MIT professor John Dower made this link explicit in a recent lecture.
There are many issues before this country but I can't consider them when I vote this fall. The economy, the underlying war on terror, social and tax issues, a host of things. On some issues I agree with Democrats, and on others with Republicans.
But if I vote for George W. Bush, I'm endorsing what happened on his watch. The Secretary of Defense says he accepts full responsibility. The President says he stands behind the Secretary. I take them at their word, but I'm their boss. So the buck stops here.
The blood and horror of Abu Ghraib will remain on my hands, on all our hands, even after November. But the cleansing process must begin.
Comments (2)
+ TrackBacks (0) | Category: Politics
- RELATED ENTRIES
- The Legend of Dennis Hayes
- Evolution Changes Its Mind (Again)
- Welcome to 1966
- What Must Craigslist Do?
- No Such Thing as Free WiFi
- The Internet As A Political Issue
- Google Images Ruled Illegal
- Fall of Radio Shack
1. Byna on May 12, 2004 02:49 AM writes...
But voting for Kerry means you endorse his policies.
You need to determine a couple of things:
% you agree with Bush
Degree you disagree with Bush
% you disagree with Bush
Degree you agree with Bush
% you agree with Kerry
Degree you disagree with Kerry
% you disagree with Kerry
Degree you agree with Kerry
I think that once you calm down you'll realize that as distastefull as it is, you have to vote for Bush becaue a vote for Kerry is a vote for appeasement.
Permalink to Comment2. Brad Hutchings on May 12, 2004 03:41 AM writes...
Oh geez Dana... Name one issue you agree with the Republicans on. Your blog has been basically two things for as long as I've read it: (1) informative and inciteful posts about technology and (2) gratuitous Bush bashing. This post is yet another example of the favorite sport of the American political and chattering classes: false indignation and posturing.
If you'd like to see brutality, Drudge (yes, I know, if he posts the pics, they are probably fabricated, just like the stain on Monica's dress) has some stills of a 26 year old American entrepreneur who felt compelled to do something to help in Iraq. The Perseus/Medusa pose is the money shot. I know it's asking too much for the chatterers to have a sense of proportion, but alot of Americans are asking.
Permalink to Comment