Corante

About this Author
Dana Dana Blankenhorn has been a business journalist for over 25 years and has covered the online world professionally since 1985. He founded the "Interactive Age Daily" for CMP Media, and has written for the Chicago Tribune, Advertising Age, and dozens of other publications over the years.
About this Site
Moore’s Law defines the history of technology. It held that the number of circuits etched on a given piece of silicon could double every 18 months as far as its author, Intel co-founder Gordon Moore, could see. Moore’s Law has spawned constant revolutions since then, not just in computing but in communications, in science, in a host of areas. Moore’s Law applies to radios, and to optical fiber, but there are some areas where it doesn’t apply. In this blog we’ll take a daily look at new implications of Moore’s Law in real time, as it rolls forward to create our future.
Media Bloggers
In the Boston area?: Join us on June 11 for Startups and the Cloud, a free event on cloud computing with insights from Intuit founder Scott Cook and others

Moore's Lore

« American Diaspora 9 | Main | A Giant Falls »

February 28, 2005

The Blog Crucible

Email This Entry

Posted by Dana Blankenhorn

To many journalists today bloggers seem to be the new plague.

Someone does something or says something "the mob" doesn't like and within days there's a virtual lynching.

But Paul McMasters is wrong. The problem is not that bloggers are attacking.

The problem is that no one's defending. And no one is getting underneath the mob, finding its sources, and placing the same spotlight on its leaders that they place on the powerful.

In his heartfelt commentary on the subject McMasters fails at that job, too. He wants "them" to stop, but to let "mainstream media" go on, as before. It comes off as special pleading.

In so many recent cases -- Ward Churchill, Larry Summers, Eason Jordan -- major institutions have fallen on their swords when attacked by a few bloggers. This despite the fact that the people in question were merely doing what bloggers themselves do, speaking their minds.

Without stating it in so many words, McMasters is comparing the blogger mentality to that of Salem villagers in the late Arthur Miller's classic "The Crucible."

The witch trials ended only when people had the courage to fire back when attacked, to get under the mob to the conspiracy behind the curtain. This is something CNN in particular has been unwilling to do, and McMasters hasn't done it here, either.

Don't just cry foul. Fire back with facts. Defend someone's to annoy bloggers as fiercely as bloggers defend their own rights. The right to attack brings with it the responsibility to defend.

Anyone without the courage of their convictions quickly finds they have none. The fault is not with the "blog mob" but with those who cry victimhood yet retreat under its gaze.

If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.

Comments (1) + TrackBacks (0) | Category: Internet | Journalism | blogging | ethics


COMMENTS

1. Eitan Caspi on February 28, 2005 04:23 PM writes...

Mr. McMasters wrote a sound of reason in this rocky times for the media.
I believe he simply asks the bloggers to calm down.

A journalist resigning because of them is not a better democracy and it should not be the target.
Silencing your opponent is not the goal. It is anti-democracy.
The spotlight should not be on the person but on the process.
The goal is to conduct a debate and, if possible, reach decisions.
Bloggers should NOT set the media's agenda by force.

You are asking the media to "fight back". Is this wise?
Do you wish for the media to chase back every main critic blogger? It will be a goose chase.
It is not the media's roll.
After all, bloggers are CUSTOMERS of the media – should it act against them for legitimate (or not-so-legitimate) claims?

Media is shocked by blogging and thus it reacts. In shock.
For the first time "Democracy's watch dog" has its own watch dog… scary… 
Media will have to make a "house check", clean it stables and rearrange itself.
After this will happen (few years at least) – maybe, just maybe then – the media will have a reason to react back on bloggers (which are growing to be competitors to the traditional media. Another problematic issue).

Customers are not willing to take any more the current illnesses of the media – and they are speaking loud and clear (although not so politely…).

Permalink to Comment

TrackBack URL:
http://www.corante.com/cgi-bin/mt/backtar.cgi/7093


EMAIL THIS ENTRY TO A FRIEND

Email this entry to:

Your email address:

Message (optional):




RELATED ENTRIES
The Legend of Dennis Hayes
Evolution Changes Its Mind (Again)
Welcome to 1966
What Must Craigslist Do?
No Such Thing as Free WiFi
The Internet As A Political Issue
Google Images Ruled Illegal
Fall of Radio Shack